Welcome to New York Pizza Plattsburgh
At New York Pizza Plattsburgh, the heart of true New York-style pizza beats strong. Located at 291 Margaret St, this cozy spot is the brainchild of a passionate owner from the Bronx, dedicated to crafting authentic pizza pies using homemade sauce and fresh ingredients. Each pie, including classics like Pepperoni and specialty Sicilian, is a testament to quality and flavor. Patrons rave about the generous cheese and expertly balanced dough, making every bite unforgettable. While the cash-only, no-frills approach adds to its charm, the welcoming atmosphere creates a community hub for pizza lovers. Come for the incredible pizza; stay for the warmth of a place that values craftsmanship.
-
291 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901 Hotline: (518) 563-0677
Welcome to New York Pizza Plattsburgh, a hidden gem located at 291 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901. This vibrant pizza haven brings the authenticity of New York City-style pizza right to the heart of upstate New York. With a passionate owner from the Bronx, it’s no wonder that locals rave about the quality and taste that defines this establishment.
The menu is a delightful collection of specialty pizzas that cater to a variety of tastes. You can indulge in the savory BBQ Chicken Pizza ($18.99), or opt for the classic White Pizza with ricotta cheese and no sauce for just $13.99. For those leaning toward something truly fresh, the All Veggie Pizza ($15.99) bursts with toppings, while the Italian Companolia Pizza ($14.99) boasts garlic, tomatoes, fresh basil, and parmesan for a flavor explosion. If you're craving something spicy, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza ($18.99) and Sicilian Style Pizza ($14.99) promise to satisfy that urge perfectly.
For those who enjoy pizza pies in a traditional sense, you can explore choices from the Salami Pizza Pie ($12.99) to the Mushroom Pizza Pie ($12.99). Each option is crafted with care, proving that simple ingredients can create extraordinary flavors.
Start your meal off right with tempting appetizers like Boneless Chicken Wings ($6.99) or Mozzarella Sticks ($5.50), which pair beautifully with any pizza order. The warmth of the service complements the delicious menu, making every visit memorable.
The reviews say it all. Customers consistently highlight the friendly atmosphere and the owner's dedication to using only the best ingredients. One patron shared, “This place is fantastic and Bill is awesome. A real down-to-earth dude who only uses the best ingredients in his pizza.” It’s this commitment to quality that has earned New York Pizza Plattsburgh its loyal following.
However, it's worth noting that the restaurant operates on a cash-only basis, and at times, you might find it best to visit in person as phone orders can be challenging to secure. “You won't find pizza this good in 300 miles,” claims one enthusiastic customer, perfectly capturing the essence of what makes this little pizzeria stand out.
If you’re in the Plattsburgh area and have yet to experience New York Pizza Plattsburgh, you owe it to yourself to visit. Whether you grab a slice on the spot or take home a delicious pie, you’re in for a delightful culinary experience that embodies the true spirit of New York pizza.
For inquiries and orders, you can reach them at (518) 563-0677. Just remember, cash only! Come hungry and leave happy!
Amazing man. He works for and by himself to make authentic NY city style pizza. Great food! Always a good dinner when I order NY Pizza.
The absolute best pizza in Plattsburgh for New York style.. homemade sauce. And super fresh cheese and lots of it. Vajed to perfection every time. Cash only , pizza only. Friendly owner. Good location. Parking just outside door and parking
Amazing pizza, quick, hot with reasonable prices! Call and don't give up if he's too busy to answer. Stop in! Cash only!
Best pizza in Plattsburgh. Guy is from the Bronx so he understands what good pizza is. Cash only.
It's good when they are actually open. When that is? Who knows. They don't pick up the phone. They simply just do not. Users say to just go inside. Good luck figuring out which door it is, and even when you do, its a coin toss if anyone is actually inside.
This place is fantastic and Bill is awesome I love the guy! A real down to earth dude who only uses the best ingredients in his pizza. I've never met somebody who cares so much about how his pizzas come out and they are consistently great. I hope he keeps it up for a long time!
Just ordered for the first time tonight after hearing great reviews. My opinion is that this is a pizza shop that deserves to label it's pizza as pie. All pie is pizza, but not all pizza is pie. Absolutely delicious NY style pie at a great price. My daughter will have a fit of rage over being asked to eat one slice of pizza, but voluntarily at 4 slices of pie from New York Pizza.
Best pizza I've had since moving to Vermont 8 years ago. It's a two hour round trip for me to go get it and it's worth every minute. The owner is so friendly and grateful for the business.
All I can say is I'm a pizza snob. You will not find pizza this good in 300 miles of any direction, your choosing. They don't do by the slice because who only eats on slice if pizza anyway??! Or rather you won't be able to stop at just one. The sauce and cheese is perfect. I can easily say this us the best pizza in plattsburgh.
Very good pizza, best in Plattsburgh....tasty sauce and great cheese ...and dough is legit. Best you will find in this area....lil small hole in the wall place.....thats where the good food is found...Owner is from Bronx and hes a cool cat too. Call ahead....good eats. #BuddhaReview